Truthinescity in Titirangi | Book Events | LeafSalon
Truthinescity in Titirangi

A thousand blessings rain upon the head of long-term LeafSalon faithful Curtbutnotshort: he has manfully ignored a ridiculous workload in order to bring us this - a thoughtful and smirkworthy insight into his Going West festival last weekend. Thank you, Curt - it's made this Kiwi cultural exile very happy.

My weekend at Going West was interrupted with tempering the PA at Eden Park (but was unable to dampen Wellington supporters) and paternal duties [Curt is a sound engineer, and yes, father, in real life - Ed.], however I did manage to lap up Friday evening and most of Saturday’s events.

The festival opened with Karlo Mila giving the Allen Curnow reading: a soliloquy on poetry and the death of a king. Her observations were punctuated with photographs: vivid images of fire lining the route of the funeral procession and the passion of the proceeding riot – scores of children kneeling by the roadside in formal attire, a lone child succumbed to the heat and occasion, Tongan dignitaries wrapped like Californian rolls.

Chris Price then presented the keynote address on the increasing prevalence of 'truthiness' (statements that sound true but which have no basis in fact) in both journalism but also literature. Whilst there can be little argument that truthiness is an unwelcome guest in news reporting its use is more ambiguous in literature and the blurring of fiction and history/biography appears to be at the bleeding edge. I personally was unfazed by James Frey’s outing and remembered having a good laugh on LeafSalon at the posts of Norma Khouri doing a Winston.

Chris’s concern was that these books were likely to have failed if they had been read/reviewed as fiction but the public were/are willing to make concessions for books presented as non-fiction (obviously we have to raise our expectations of biographical prose). I don’t think truthiness is new – is it not similar to a white lie? Though it may be pervading through journalism there are just as many information sources questioning its veracity. But too many truthinesses just muddy the water and what are we left to believe? The talk was well-referenced and I wished she had handed out a reading sheet for further investigation.

But as Murray Gray pointed out, the weekend had only just begun and already we were half an hour behind – the next performance was going to have to be good to hold off supper. It was better. Eight Pacific Island poets performing 'Polynation' – the men sharing history and social commentary with ukulele and spoken voice. The women prowled and owned the stage, including Serie Barford, Karlo Milo who kept a haiku beneath her heel, and Tusiata Avia who was unable to contain the wild dogs under her skirt.

The evening concluded on the step of the hall with the ever-patient security guards waiting for the last glass to be consumed, fag to be stubbed and opinion to be concluded.

Saturday warmed up with the environment and the discussion panel certainly got a friendly ear from the early risers. Judging from the queue at the local café we will all be happy to make a few sacrifices as long as the carbon tax does not put too high a price on coffee.

I felt the 'China Down Under' session was disappointing as the panel appeared to be constrained by the theme. Three of the four panellists were born in New Zealand and all wrote in English. All appeared to want to be considered as kiwis with a proud Chinese ancestry rather than the other way around and appeared uncomfortable having to question their ethnicity and its role in their writing.

Unfortunately Eden Park beckoned halfway through the Nigel Cox session (what sort of truthiness shrouds Elvis Presley and his childhood in Mississippi – when will the world learn of his battles with the giant weta in the Wairarapa?). He appeared in a video interview and I was struck by his mana and quiet dignity. In the shop later I was drawn to his first two novels which he frequently warned people away from. However, I found the Berlin experience far more interesting and was distracted into purchasing his essays on his time there instead.

Mayor Bob Harvey is the much-loved, worn corduroy jacket of the Waitakeres and Going West should instigate the Harvey interview from now on, although the interviewee will have to tussle with Bob to get a word in. Hamish Keith proved equal to the task, and together they traversed the dodgy Waitakere transport of their youth; transforming the Labour party in the 70’s (doing a Trinnie and Susannah on Norman Kirk and changing him from fat to big); the need to overcome stereotypes of the country seen as young and rural and finally, Te Papa which could have filled the rest of the weekend if the bar hadn’t opened first.

The final session on Saturday and my last for the weekend was 'Homegrown' chaired by Nick Bollinger and discussing the documentation of music in New Zealand. This was interesting as it had both musicians and journalists on stage – although the line was largely blurred as most appeared to be journalists/writers and musicians. The vein most frequently mined was that the music journalists/critics herald small and obscure bands whilst ignoring the more popular and successful bands.

The defence was that critics had a wealth of material to digest, which gave rise to a more discerning taste – not mentioning names but I thought that Ian Morris was remarkably restrained, as it appeared to me that he was being told that the critics weren’t reviewing his bands because they had access to better, more obscure music and that the public only liked popular music because they didn’t. John Dix gave us the gossip we wanted to hear and Nick Bollinger was largely drowned out by the women surrounding me who couldn’t believe his age and were ready to toss brief items onto the stage.

Hopefully someone can fill you in on Sunday – most of the above actually happened, honest.

24 Sep 08 | Filed by Kathy | Add your comment (11 so far)

Get the latest LeafSalon articles delivered to your inbox as soon as they're published.  If you enjoyed this post, get free updates by email.

Comment by mary mac ~ September 25, 2008 3:55 PM

Great post Curtbutnotshort - trouble is it stops half way through a word! I am hanging out for more... or perhaps you literally did stop there to head off to the rugby.


Comment by Islander ~ September 25, 2008 5:37 PM

O bugger- why does curtbutnotshort's coverage of "Going West" all is good for those of us who now dont go to litfest things stop short?


Comment by Kathy ~ September 25, 2008 6:01 PM

Sorry guys, temporary glitch - fixed now. Refresh your screens and all will be well. The problem is that LeafSalon is now so venerable that the software we set it up with is on its last legs and the whole site is full which leads to these kinds of drop-offs.
Gird your loins for the end. Really.


Comment by Islander ~ September 25, 2008 8:01 PM

And enjoyed/appreciated the reportage-cheers!


Comment by maggie ~ September 27, 2008 8:29 AM

Curt, the noise you were trying to dampen wasn't coming from Eden Park, it was coming all the way from people like me in their living rooms in Wellington.

Thanks so much for continuing the "Westies' Lament" on behalf of Kathy who couldn't make it.
What an enviable, elecletic mix of cultural offerings from the 'Going West' Festival - it doesn't sound like the usual literary festival filled to the formal front rows with grey bobs... oh whoops, if I didn't use the magic shampoo, I'd be one too.

Definitely sounds like a festival to get to (next year!).


Comment by Chris Price ~ October 23, 2008 11:26 AM

I thought LeafSalonistas might like to know that the 2008 Going West keynote address (with some extra material not included on the night) is now available on the New Zealand Book Council website here:
www.bookcouncil.org.nz/writers/Going_West_keynote.pdf

Farhad Manjoo's recent book, True Enough: Learning to Live in a Post-fact Society (John Wiley, 2008) provides a discussion that ranges well beyond the confines of literature into politics and the media, and is particularly good on the role of the Internet in destabilising earlier notions of reality or 'truth'. Here's a quote from his introduction: 'Political scientists have characterised our epoch as one of heightened polarisation; now... the creeping partisanship has begun to distort our very perceptions about what is “real” and what isn’t. Indeed you can go so far as to say we’re now fighting over competing versions of reality. And it is more convenient than ever before for some of us to live in a world built out of our own facts.' With both US and NZ elections looming, it makes for thought-provoking reading.

Inga Clendinnen's excellent essay ‘The History Question: Who Owns the Past?’ (Quarterly Essay, Issue 23, Black Inc., 2006) is also well worth hunting out. She does a great deconstruction of Australia's unofficial anthem, 'Waltzing Matilda', along the way...


Comment by Renee Liang ~ December 4, 2008 3:00 PM

Hi Curt, thanks for your review - it was a fabulous weekend! I'm curious though - you mentioned in your review of the "China Down Under" session that "All appeared to want to be considered as kiwis with a proud Chinese ancestry rather than the other way around."

Why exactly is this a problem? We were born here: that makes us Kiwis, writing from a Kiwi point of view. The extra addition of our Chinese ancestry adds an interesting twist, and it certainly seems to be the part a lot of people want to hear about, but it certainly isn't all we write about.

When we met beforehand to discuss the session we all agreed that we should respond to our brief by talking about our work as writers rather than as Kiwis of Asian descent. Our "discomfort", as you saw it, of "having to question (our) ethnicity and its role in (our) writing, is more a product of our wish to be considered as writers first, on our own merits. This is not to say that we ignore the role our ethnicity plays on our writing - which locates us both 'inside' and 'outside', a great place to be creatively.


Comment by Islander ~ December 8, 2008 11:59 PM

Renee Liang - the exact reaction occurred when Maori writers (we are both NZers & Maori, but readers from other backgrounds were most interested in the taha Maori) first were being published.
Well, i guess our literary nation will grow up. Soon.


Comment by Islander ~ December 9, 2008 12:03 AM

Renee Liang- the same reaction occurred way back in the 1970s when Maori were first being published. Obviously we were NZers as well as Maori but...may literary ANZ grow up soon!


Comment by curtbutnotshort ~ December 9, 2008 1:18 PM

Renee - you reiterate my point. I see you as a writer first. I felt that the emphasis of the questions should have been on the groups work and how your cultural heritage had influenced the creative process but instead the discussion frequently returned to the process of being Asian in NZ. That is what diappointed me.


Comment by curtbutnotshort ~ December 9, 2008 1:18 PM

Renee - you reiterate my point. I see you as a writer first. I felt that the emphasis of the questions should have been on the groups work and how your cultural heritage had influenced the creative process but instead the discussion frequently returned to the process of being Asian in NZ. That is what disappointed me.


Email Truthinescity in Titirangi to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):


New Zealand Book Forum
FREE email subscription!
New books shipped free
Fast used book search