Well, Cinders went to the ball last night at the very last minute, but I’m afraid I didn’t make it home till well past midnight … But you’ll be glad to know that pumpkin was not on the menu. The food was great, the wine superb (of course), the company glittering and most of the awards were spot on.
I have to say first though that the awards will never be forgotten by me or probably anyone who was there due to the extraordinary wheelchair presence of Mr Nigel Cox, who won joint runner up in the Fiction award. Extraordinary because Nigel is most gravely ill - as most of you will know from the Listener article this week. In fact it’s amazing that he made it up from Wellington at all.
Nigel's heartbreaking speech left hardened publishers choking in their napkins. You could have heard a pin drop as Nigel spoke the kindness of people, of finding that ‘you come to realise that everyone has a well of kindness in them that is just waiting for circumstances like these to flood out.’ Nigel the man, and his work, left us better people last night. In the midst of the glamour and glitz there was a deep, slow motion, frighteningly human silence as he spoke.
I so desperately wanted Nigel to win. I don’t want to take anything from the winners by saying this, but god – I really, really did. Even Elizabeth Knox did (she said with heartwarming honesty 'Dreamhunter can take care of itself' - the book is in the recent top ten Young Adult fiction in the US). And I have to say it – there should have been something at these awards – something more – to acknowledge what I believe is and will increasingly become, as these things do, a body of work that we will all look back on and marvel at.
What book could possibly ever come near Tarzan Presley? May Giant Nigerian Archive Earwigs forever nibble the ankles of anyone who can put down that book and say they are not changed in some way. However, the good news is that Nigel has finished his latest book, and we can look forward to reading The Cowboy Dog at some stage in the future. Meanwhile I'm wearing my Cowboy Dog button, courtesy of a certain publisher. Anyway. Onward.
As for the rest of it: I’ll put you out of your misery straight away, as if you don't already know – the most excellent Maurice Gee’s novel Blindsight (Penguin Books) won the Deutz Medal for Fiction or Poetry in the Montana New Zealand Book Awards 2006. This was a most auspicious win for ‘this country's greatest living novelist’ happily at the end of his career (in adult fiction at least, but he is writing a children’s book at present) and our heartiest congratulations go to Mr Gee.
However, it does unfortunately prove once and for all that if a book of poetry did not get the gong in 2006, it almost certainly never will, because it’s hard to imagine a better book of poetry than Bill Manhire’s Lifted. Which is a depressing thought. Maurice had quite a good, manly line to take the prize with though: ‘I wouldn’t have minded losing to Bill. But I didn’t.’
Pohutukawa & Rata: New Zealand's Iron-hearted Trees (Te Papa Press) by the ebullient Philip Simpson won the Montana Medal for Non Fiction. The judges kept banging on that it was very readable and I must say having flipped through it here and there that Philip’s large personality does shine through and it’s a book every Kiwi should own, that’s for sure. The Project Crimson table was whoopin’ and a-hollerin’. I’d dearly like someone to explain to me the reason behind the itsy-bitsy, rather weedy-looking pohutakawa on the cover though. I mean, you think of these trees, you think big, right? There must be a reason...
For the very first time since the Readers' Choice Award was introduced in 1998,
the public vote was evenly split between Blindsight and Fiona Kidman's The Captive Wife (Vintage). Fiona and Maurice linked arms and swanned up the steps, and Fiona said ‘that felt like getting married again!’ Then she made some rather saucy comments about writing being like any of the unmentionable acts one does in private and thanked her readers most prettily for, in effect, getting her out in public. Quite a hoot.
The other prizes were:
Biography: Dingle: Discovering the Sense in Adventure by Graeme Dingle
(Craig Potton Publishing) – Graeme commented that ‘it was a long way from getting 50% in School Cert English to the stage at the Montanas’;
History: Thrift to Fantasy: Home Textile Crafts of the 1930s - 1950s by Rosemary McLeod (HarperCollins Publishers) – Rosemary said she felt like a charlatan because she is really a journalist and this is all, like, literature, but jeez, that’s a great book. My only gripe here? Where, oh where was Vantastic? Sigh.
Reference & Anthology: Great Sporting Moments: The best of Sport magazine 1988–2004 edited by Damien Wilkins (Victoria University Press) – well what can you say. Still dipping into this brilliant anthology, still being surprised and delighted every time.
Lifestyle & Contemporary Culture: How to Look at a Painting by Justin Paton (Awa Press) – oh Justin! How we love you and your very stylish, very pregnant partner Vita… this has to be one of the best lil’ books around. Huge congrats here too to gorgeous, bubbly Mary Varnham with her great ideas. Up the AWA!
Illustrative: Contemporary New Zealand Photographers edited by Hannah Holm and Lara Strongman (Mountain View Publishing).
But before that there were the best first book awards for non-fiction, poetry, and fiction which were established by the New Zealand Society of Authors with the aim of encouraging new writers and their publishers. This year's competition was fierce with 36 books of non-fiction, nine of poetry, and nine of fiction vying for the awards. They’re always such a mouthful, but here they are:
New Zealand Society of Authors E H McCormick Best First Book Award for Non Fiction – Pakeha and the Treaty: Why it's Our Treaty too by Patrick Snedden (Random House NZ). Patrick’s acceptance speech was most beguiling;
New Zealand Society of Authors Jessie Mackay Best First Book Award for Poetry – Dream Fish Floating by Karlo Mila (Huia Publishers). The judges said, 'Karlo Mila writes with flair, energy and passion, creating a direct, accessible poetry. This multi-cultural, lyrical voice is one the judges expect to hear a lot more of.’ Oh yeah. Karlo is exuberance and charm personified.
New Zealand Society of Authors Hubert Church Best First Book Award for Fiction – A Red Silk Sea by Gillian Ranstead (Penguin Books). ‘A Red Silk Sea is ambitious in its sweep, consciously literary in its language, it is a strong début book,’ said the judges.
The A W Reed award for contribution to New Zealand literature was presented to the delectable Kevin Ireland. This award is presented biennially in recognition of an outstanding contribution to New Zealand literature and an involvement in activities which foster and promote literature to wider audiences.
Now, this very evening, he has emailed me about a little job I asked him to do (blogging for the NZ Book Month website) saying ‘I'm the sole judge for the BNZ Mansfield stories and since they're up to (and some are over) 5000 words, I have over a million words to get through, and I'm also doing an essay competition for North Shore Secondary schools. Please have mercy.’ So I think he’s probably a good choice. LeafSalon’s big congrats to another of our greatest living writers, and a very styley geezer to boot.
The Reviewer of the Year Award was Jolisa Gracewood, most deservedly - congratulations Jolisa, and the Best Review Page or Programme Award was Wellington’s Dominion Post. If only we had something as fab up here in Auckland – four whole pages devoted to books. Still, there’s always the Listener.
Well, that about wraps it up. I must say, I agreed with the judges’ wrap comments: 'The judging panel was impressed with how well New Zealand writing and publishing served the differing but overlapping reading publics of this culture. For a society with a comparatively small population base, the range of what is being written and published is great indeed, and across that range the quality is high.'
Hear, hear.
25 Jul 06 | Filed by Kathy | Add your comment (12 so far)Comment by fergus ~ July 26, 2006 8:40 AM
I have to say, I feel terribly disappointed at Lifted's not winning the Deutz Medal -- and after 36 hours so it's not the hangover. This is in no way a criticism of the winner. Maurice Gee is one of our greatest. Plumb changed my life more than any other book, when I read it as an impressionable 18-year-old, completely uncertain about which direction to take at university. And Blindsight is a superb novel which had me completely enthralled. However, Lifted is a book of a different and rare order -- it's a book which stands in Bill's oeuvre and in NZ literature in a position very similar to Plumb in Maurice's, and it's very disappointing that it hasn't been recognised by this award.
What happened? The judges' report (http://www.booksellers.co.nz/documents/mnzba_judges_rpt06.pdf) says, "the choice came down to community impact, and here we thought that Blindsight had a slight edge". Does this just mean sales? If so, it's now official: Poetry can never win the Deutz Medal and the "play-off" stands revealed as an empty gimmick which attempts to create a completely false sense of excitement.
But if you take a wider view of "community impact", and take into account Sir Edmund Hillary's reading of "Erebus Voices" at the 25th anniversary of the disaster; Bill's many electrifying public readings of "Hotel Emergencies"; the very warm responses to "Opoutere", BIll's elegy for Michael King; and the requests to reproduce or quote from these and other poems; then it's clear that Lifted has already had and will go on to have a significantly greater "community impact". If you want further evidence, how about the warmer media reporting of the poetry category announcement on Friday?
OK. With that out of my system, I must say how happy I was that Damien was rewarded for Great Sporting Moments -- especially as all those who have helped me most with the magazine were there, shortlisted for other achievements. Thank you Damien, Elizabeth, Nigel, James and Bill!
And finally, what extraordinary courage and grace Nigel showed in his appearance and acceptance speech.
Comment by Damien Wilkins ~ July 26, 2006 9:46 AM
Nice report, Kathy.
'Lifted' is my Book of the Year; Nigel is my Man of the Year; and Nigel's beautiful comment about 'the reservoir of human kindness' is my Phrase of the Year.
Comment by maggie ~ July 26, 2006 11:01 AM
I think Paula Morris put it well when she summarised the short-list and said "Now is the time to honour him and his unique, substantial, exuberant body of work." (about Nigel Cox) - perhaps the judges were too seriously circumpsect and didn't want to appear sentimental - what a shame!
About "Red Silk Sea" - I felt the book over-reached with too many big themes - white trash meets Once Were Warriors and the holocaust - and if you borrow from such big themes the writing needs to be pared back or exceedingly beautiful - and in this case, I don't think it quite got there. But, I hated "Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close" by Jonathan Safran Foer, (for the same reasons)which got rave reviews. And just in case anyone thinks its sour grapes because I wasn't even nominated... well of course, it is..n't.
Comment by Chris ~ July 26, 2006 12:21 PM
On the subject of sour grapes - if we at LeafSalon don't get an invite to next year's awards, there will be hell to pay! We are, incidentally, NZ's second most popular book-related website and probably #1 if you take out NZ's biggest online book retailer.
Kathy's presence and subsequent report was due to a freebie ticket given to her at the last minute by a kind soul who couldn't make it.
Comment by Robert Sullivan ~ July 26, 2006 1:20 PM
Kia ora taatou,
I'm adding my support for Nigel, too. He should have won handsomely for his major contributions to NZ letters. That was an opportune moment to recognize him, where the book community was gathered, amongst his peers. This reflects poorly on the awards if you believe that they represent more than just recognition for sales.
I know what it is like to be an awards judge (overseas) and it isn't a pretty spot to be in if you know some of the contenders. It can't be easy in a country the size of NZ. There'll be some soul-searching I hope amongst the jurors.
I don't believe this is our finest hour as a writing community.
Comment by Angela A ~ July 26, 2006 5:20 PM
Fergus, I think it is absolutely clear from the judges' report that poetry can never win the Deutz Medal.
As you say, the judges felt the two books were neck and neck until they got to the fourth general judging criterion, that of "community impact". Quoting from the report, community impact takes into account "factors such as topicality, public interest, commercial viability, entertainment, cultural and educational values, lifespan and value for money." How are these measured? I would love to know how the judges compare levels of "public interest" and "entertainment value", without relying entirely on sales.
What are these awards about? It is clear from the winners that they are about quality, but ultimately, quality that sells well is worth more than quality that doesn't. Unless the stars align so that some sort of Billy Collins emerges in NZ, and fiction happens to have a very bad year, poetry is always going to be pipped at the post by the "community impact" clause.
Either:
a) The "community impact" idea needs to be revised so that it is specifically not about sales (perhaps the solution would be to can it);
b) The Deutz Medal concept of pitting poetry against fiction should be ditched; or
c) We accept that the Montana Book Awards have limited credibility, though this option is less desirable since the awards will continue to exert significant influence over the public perception of "how good" a book is, poetry will continue to be overlooked and hey presto! we have a self-fulfilling prophecy: poetry has less community impact than fiction.
Comment by Diane ~ July 27, 2006 12:12 PM
Just a bit of background re poetry being in the Fiction section. Up until 2004 poetry was lumped in with the Montana Non-fiction section. In 2003 my book 8 Stages of Grace (a verse novel) caused some difficulties as to which category it should go in. Eventually it was accepted in the novel section and longlisted. Subsequently some of us backed by the NZ Society of Authors campaigned to have poetry judged alongside fiction for the Deutz Medal. We thought poetry would have a better chance than being judged alongside nonfiction. It's still a tall order however, given the judging criteria of the Montanas particularly the community impact criteria.
Personally I think there is now so much underhand campaigning and politicking going on in the Montanas, it's about time we had other literary awards that are purely about literary excellence and originality.
Comment by Mark Hubbard ~ July 27, 2006 1:55 PM
Diane: you have published a novel in verse. That sound's interesting. What is it?
Comment by Philip Matthews ~ July 27, 2006 2:06 PM
I agree with Damien. The phrase that has stayed with me from Monday night is Nigel Cox's line about the reservoirs of human kindness. When we've all forgotten who won or lost, we will all remember that speech, I'm sure. It was very moving and the standing ovation that followed said more about Nigel than any award could. Otherwise, the night could only have been improved if they had themed it country and western style as in Sunday's bizarre Booksellers/Book Design Awards, er, barndance.
Comment by kara ~ July 27, 2006 2:12 PM
Hi, nice site.
Why don't you have an 'ask' category? Would be helpful for all those who need info/would like to share info on lit. events.
Thanks,
Kara
P.S: I know, it is not the place, but don't know where on this site I can ask this question!
Comment by Diane Brown ~ July 27, 2006 2:42 PM
A verse novel? Ahh... a novel in verse. It's not rhyming, and is relatively easy to read. Contemporary, about two women living in new territories, one an immigrant from Korea, one a widow. Set in Piha, published by Vintage (Random 2002)
Comment by graham ~ August 1, 2006 12:20 AM
Lifted is a fine book with some terrific poems in it. A better book, a great book, Milk and Honey, was not shortlisted.

ISSN #1176-4465. LeafSalon is licensed under a 
